For over a century, legislation designed to protect construction workers has gone through numerous changes. One of the most significant is known as New York’s Scaffold Law, a law enacted to protect the rights of construction workers who work at high elevations. Due to the number of height-related injuries and fatalities, it’s now a legal requirement to provide safety precautions, such as proper scaffolding and sturdy ladders. However, some argue that the law has had a negative financial impact on contracting firms. This debate has prompted the need for new legislation to enhance the law’s effectiveness. If you or someone you love works in construction, staying up-to-date with safety laws is invaluable for protecting yourself in the event of an injury. A Suffolk County construction accident lawyer can help keep you informed about protections for construction workers and provide the legal representation you need.
Impact on the Construction Industry
Supporters of the Scaffold Law argue it has saved countless lives. In an industry where falls are one of the leading causes of workplace fatalities, laws that prioritize safety save lives. In fact, the rate of construction injuries in New York is higher than the national average, particularly from falls.
Critics, however, claim the law drives up the cost of construction in New York by millions of dollars annually. Due to the strict liability standard, insurance premiums for construction-related policies are significantly higher in New York compared to other states. As a result, contracting firms face significant financial challenges. But construction sites aren’t the only ones affected. Public works projects, such as schools and highways, often cost taxpayers more because of the increased risk to contractors.
Minority- and women-owned contracting firms are particularly affected, facing additional challenges in handling insurance costs required for public projects. Some contractors argue that the law creates an unfair burden, limiting opportunities and discouraging business growth. For these reasons, the Scaffold Law remains one of the most controversial pieces of legislation in New York’s labor landscape.
Current Reform Efforts and Legislative Debate
In 2025, New York legislators introduced Senate Bill S8200 to require insurers to disclose detailed data on Scaffold Law-related claims. The goal is to increase transparency and better assess the law’s impact on the state’s economy and legal system.
Other proposals, including federal exemptions for federally funded projects, suggest adopting a comparative negligence standard. This approach would allow juries to assign a percentage of fault to both the worker and the contractor, rather than automatically holding contractors fully responsible. Supporters argue that this would curb abuse while preserving protections; opponents argue that any rollback would weaken safeguards, shift costs to injured workers, discourage reporting, and promote unsafe practices.
Recent rulings also narrow the law’s scope, requiring plaintiffs to show they were engaged in a covered activity (construction, demolition, or repair) and that a safety-device failure caused the injury. These developments complicate claims, and presentation errors can result in dismissal.
Why Legal Strategy From a Suffolk County Construction Accident Lawyer Matters
Strict liability may sound simple, but the defense is a complex legal maze. Insurers often argue that the worker was the cause of the injury, or that the task wasn’t a covered activity. They also challenge the adequacy of evidence: Was the equipment truly missing or defective? Were you performing assigned work? Did any witness statements contradict your claim?
This is where skilled legal strategy comes in. An experienced construction accident lawyer familiar with the history, application, and current debates surrounding the Scaffold Law is vital. Their experience enables them to build stronger cases, navigate the legal system effectively, and advocate for the compensation they deserve.
Without proper legal handling, even strong cases risk falling apart. Comprehensive representation ensures that your voice is heard and your injuries are taken seriously.
Get the Guidance You Need From a Suffolk County Construction Accident Lawyer
If you’ve been injured in a scaffold-related incident, you need someone who knows the law, understands your pain, and will fight to protect your future. Call Matera & Manley, LLP, today to schedule a free consultation with a trusted construction accident lawyer. The right legal support can make all the difference in your recovery and peace of mind.
New York Labor Law §240, commonly known as the Scaffold Law, was enacted in 1885 in response to the growing number of deaths during the city’s industrial boom. Back then, workers were severely injured without any legal recourse. The law created a strict liability standard that holds property owners and contractors responsible for gravity-related injuries, regardless of the worker’s actions.
English 
Spanish