When you’ve been seriously injured, choosing the right Hauppauge personal injury lawyer isn’t just important—it’s critical. The attorney you select will guide you through a challenging time and help you fight for the compensation you deserve. But with so many firms out there, how do you know who to trust?
Below are key criteria to consider when searching for the best personal injury lawyer in Hauppauge and how Matera & Manley, LLP stands out in each category.
1. Focus on Personal Injury Law in Hauppauge
Personal injury law is nuanced and requires focused knowledge. Lawyers who regularly handle these cases are more familiar with the challenges involved, from negotiating with insurance companies to presenting compelling arguments in court.
At Matera & Manley, LLP, personal injury is one of our core practice areas. We handle a wide range of cases, including car accidents, truck accidents, slip and falls, construction accidents, wrongful death claims, and more. Our attorneys stay up to date on New York injury law to ensure our clients always receive informed and strategic representation.
2. Trial Experience and a Reputation for Litigation
Insurance companies often offer better settlements to lawyers they know are willing and able to take a case to trial. Trial experience shows you’re prepared to go the distance if necessary.
As former prosecutors, we bring decades of litigation experience and a foundation built on courtroom success. Our attorneys approach every case with the assumption that it may go to trial. That means we gather evidence thoroughly, consult with experts when needed, and develop strong legal strategies from the outset. This proactive approach has helped us secure millions in compensation for injury victims. When fair settlements aren’t offered, we’re fully prepared to advocate for our clients in court, handling cases in both state and federal jurisdictions skillfully.
3. Attorney Backgrounds That Provide a Strategic Edge
Attorneys with prosecutorial or investigative backgrounds bring a valuable perspective to personal injury law. They understand how cases are built and challenged from both sides. From this unique vantage point, our attorneys develop strategies that anticipate the opposition’s moves and strengthen every aspect of your case.
As lifelong Long Island residents, Michaelangelo Matera and Jonathan B. Manley also have deep ties to the local community and a firsthand understanding of the legal landscape in Suffolk County and beyond. Michaelangelo Matera began his legal career at the Bronx County District Attorney’s Office, where he tried cases ranging from misdemeanors to homicides. Jonathan Manley, a former Suffolk County prosecutor, led complex investigations into financial crimes and major felonies. Their combined experience—and their roots in the region—give them a unique ability to serve clients looking for a Hauppauge personal injury lawyer who knows both the law and the community they represent.
4. Proven Results as a Hauppauge Personal Injury Lawyer
Past performance isn’t just a selling point—it’s proof of a lawyer’s ability to succeed. When considering a lawyer to advocate for your needs, be sure to look for documented case results and verdicts. Our history of seven-figure verdicts and settlements reflects our deep commitment to client success.
Michaelangelo Matera has been recognized for securing one of the Top 50 Personal Injury Settlements in New York and is a proud member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum. This prestigious group is reserved for attorneys who have achieved individual verdicts or settlements exceeding $1 million for their clients. Additionally, Jonathan Manley has been recognized by Super Lawyers and The New York Times for his outstanding work. He also holds a perfect 10.0 AVVO rating, the highest possible rating a lawyer can achieve.
5. Reviews and Reputation
Client testimonials provide real insight into how a lawyer communicates, treats their clients, and delivers results. Lawyers build a strong reputation through consistent, high-quality representation.
“Mike Matera is hands-on, reliable, dependable, knowledgeable and has had a positive impact on the ongoing legal issues my husband has endured. Mr. Matera is composed and communicative. His patience is INVALUABLE. He shows COMPASSION, which, in my husband’s situation, is greatly appreciated. Mr. Matera’s ability to listen is the key to his talent as an attorney. It allows him to act in the best interest of his client. I highly recommend his firm.”
At Matera & Manley, LLP, we’re proud of the trust our clients place in us because we work hard to earn it every day. From the first consultation to the final resolution, we prioritize communication, compassion, and clear guidance. Reviews like the one above reflect our unwavering dedication to providing not just legal representation, but real support during challenging times.
6. Compassion and Client Communication
Personal injury cases are emotionally and physically exhausting. Your lawyer should not only be a legal expert but a guide—someone who listens, explains clearly, and stands by your side.
At our firm, clear communication is fundamental to how we serve our clients. Our extensive video library is designed to help clients understand their rights and the legal process, empowering them with knowledge from day one.
And because we believe everyone deserves access to trusted legal guidance, we offer free and confidential case consultations, allowing clients to understand their options with no pressure and no obligation.
Book a Free Consultation With a Hauppauge Personal Injury Lawyer
Choosing the right personal injury lawyer can make a big difference. It can also affect how supported you feel during a difficult time. At Matera & Manley, LLP, our combination of experience, results, and personal dedication sets us apart in Hauppauge and beyond.
We know legal emergencies don’t follow a 9-to-5 schedule. That’s why we’re available 24/7, Monday through Friday, to give you the support you need, when you need it. When your health, finances, and future are at stake, don’t settle for less. Contact us today to arrange a free and confidential case consultation.
English 
Spanish